As I wrote last week, the massive turnout of Democratic voters in traditionally Republican areas, especially in the South, is both inspiring and cautionary, since the turnout gap between Democratic voters and Republican voters likely won’t be as large in 2028, as it is a presidential year.
I want to make it clear that I’m not referring to Georgia and South Carolina, where it seems like they have become true purple states (perhaps with a slight reddish tinge). I’m referring to places that are still Republican, but where Democrats, due to a fortunate confluence of Trump’s personal awfulness, economic problems, discontent with other Republican policies, charismatic Democratic candidates, and awful Republican candidates, managed to win the seat.
Democrats should be able to keep the trend going through 2028 due to Trump’s unpopularity, but, assuming Democrats take back the presidency, 2030 will likely be a backlash election, and 2032 a midterm election, with less disparity in turnout, so many of these red seats will be lost. This will be all the more likely if some Republicans figure out how to move their party away from being a white Christian supremacist movement.
So the question many of these new red state/district Democrats need to ask is: what do you want to accomplish over the next four to six years, because that’s all you might have. In other words, will you govern like you have nothing to lose?
Caveat: Democrats could actually do things to increase their popularity, which would both increase turnout of the base groups and pick up some votes in other groups, thereby shifting more red places to purple (and, in the House, an anti-gerrymandering bill changes ‘redness’ too). I would love to see that happen, but I’m not convinced it will–the leadership battles matter!
