Because, as the old saw goes, when the facts change, I change my mind. We’ll return to those changed facts, but first, Jamelle Bouie explains why Democrats should end the Senate filibuster (boldface mine):
Most of what Democrats pass [with Trump remaining as president] will be purely symbolic — less a set of actual laws than a preview of governance under a Democratic president.
Still, passing legislation, I think, will be a good thing. In fact, Democrats should pass as much as they can, even if Trump vetoes every bill they put on his desk.
But there is a problem.
The current rules of the Senate make productivity impossible. As long as the filibuster exists, Democrats will be bogged down in endless negotiations to try to win the minimum of four votes necessary to invoke cloture. Worse, the 60-vote threshold gives every Democrat leverage over the entire agenda. If, for example, John Fetterman does not want to pass a new Voting Rights Act, then a new Voting Rights Act will not get passed. Looking at the Senate landscape, it is hard to see where Democrats would pick up additional support. At no point in the last 20 years have Republicans shown any desire to work with Democrats to pass the party’s priorities…
Put differently, the voting public did not vote for bipartisanship; they voted for Democrats to govern as Democrats. The least the next Congress could do is to respect that choice and proceed accordingly.
A year ago, I was in the camp of Democrats should wait until 2029 to end the filibuster (it did serve as a useful last chance for Democrats when they were in the minority). Why? Because, at that time, it seemed like Democrats would, if things went well, wind up with 51 senate seats (maybe 52 as a reach). Even with 52 seats, Democrats would have been one coronary event and one John Fetterman away from losing the chamber and thus catastrophe.
But with 56, the calculus is very different. Democrats can handle a defection (death)–just look at the lack of concern when Fetterman announced yesterday that he might switch parties if Van Hollen were to become majority leader.
The upside of no filibuster is Democrats can pass Democratic legislation and force Trump to veto it (though it remains to be seen if too many senate Democrats are still in thrall to the notion of bipartisanship). With a filibuster, when senate Republicans kill legislation, the story will be–and in the past has been–”Congress fails to pass…” But with passed bills vetoed by Trump, the story would be “Trump kills the Bill to Protect America’s Babies” (or whatever), and that is much better for Democrats. Unlike the procedural morass* of the filibuster, it’s clear who the problem is, and that is very useful for 2028 (alternatively, he occasionally signs good legislation).
So end the filibuster, Democrats.
*It’s also a poor excuse, as some low-information voters will correctly ask, “So why don’t you get rid off it?”
