While people often focus on the cost of housing, it’s important to realize that the costs of transportation also need to be considered. As I noted a few years ago, when you include transportation costs into the ‘cost of housing’, ‘expensive cities’ become less so, and the ‘affordable’ suburbs aren’t that affordable. Well, it appears these hidden costs aren’t remaining so hidden. From Loudoun County, VA (boldface mine):
In one decade, the fortunes of Loudoun and its homeowners have shifted as more and more people in the D.C. region have gravitated toward city life. As property values have exploded elsewhere, Lansdowne has been left behind.
Today, the Cloars can’t sell their house — even at a loss. And its value teeters at something close to that of a modest rowhouse in Washington’s Trinidad neighborhood, a once hard-knock neighborhood with high vacancy rates and violent crime in the heart of the 20002 Zip code, where house values rose an astonishing 91 percent in a dozen years…
Of all the positives home buyers cite for wanting to live in the suburbs — affordability, schools, newer homes, leafy neighborhoods where children can roam freely — one negative has gained more traction: traffic. Washington has some of the worst gridlock in the country, with Interstate 66, which connects the District to Fairfax, Loudoun and Prince William counties, earning the ignominious distinction of “worst damn freeway in America.”
…A 2011 study by the Chicago-based Center for Neighborhood Technology found that most of Loudoun County’s commuters traveled 26,000 to 35,000 miles a year to work. Less than 10 percent used public transit. They spent $1,280 to $1,770 a month on transportation, and that didn’t even account for the time sopped up sitting in traffic.
“What is the time value of the hour and a half you spend commuting each way?” Fleming said. “If you really calculated, would you have bought that home out there? That’s why all these exurban areas are struggling to recover. Because there is not the demand.”
The problem is, as I’ve noted before, it’s really hard to turn the suburban knot into an urban grid:
A net of about 1,000 people a month are still moving to Loudoun, lifting values in the eastern end of the county. If history is any indicator, a major bump could come again in 2020, when the county is scheduled to open its first three Metro stations.
But many of these neighborhoods were designed for a car culture. The worse the traffic is, the more people are attuned to walkability or access to public transportation.
“There is a part of me that wonders, if walkability is what everybody is looking for, what does that do for the neighborhoods that don’t have it?” said Christine Richardson of Weichert Realtors, who is the Cloars’ listing agent.
This, not urban housing prices, is our wicked housing problem–and it will become very politically volatile.
